Skip to content

All perspectives

Draft for Nick’s review. This note is a working draft in Nick’s voice. It is not published advice, and it is not a legal, procurement, or technical opinion until he edits it.

Trusted exchange, left out of the sentence that requires it

CMS says clinical super intelligence cannot scale without trusted data exchange. In the roadmap I read, that data foundation never names TEFCA or a health information exchange.

CMS published a roadmap for what it calls clinical super intelligence. One sentence in the data-foundation section is the whole argument, and it is the right one: clinical SI cannot scale without trusted data exchange.

Then I went looking for the exchange.

The section builds that idea on CMS Aligned Networks and the Health Tech Ecosystem. Patient access. Provider-to-provider exchange. Payer participation. Identity. I read it for TEFCA. I do not find it. I read it for health information exchanges. I do not find those either. If a later revision names them, good. The document in front of me does not.

I have spent twenty-five years on the unglamorous side of that sentence. ADT. Encounter alerts. The participation agreement. The hospital that will send the feed, and the plan or the clinic that has to do something when it arrives. When a federal roadmap says trusted exchange is the condition for scale, and then describes a data foundation without the networks already doing that work, states and HIEs inherit a second story to reconcile with the one they are funding.

Vendors hear a second story too. The way to be relevant starts to sound like a pledge inside a CMS ecosystem, rather than participation in the exchange their customers use on a Tuesday morning.

CMS Aligned Networks are real work. Patient access and identity needed the attention, and a model that reasons over a partial chart is not clinically serious. I am not asking the roadmap to pretend a query network is a feature store. ADT is a thin signal. Consent, data quality, and patient-directed access are still unfinished. The omission that bothers me is narrower than a turf defense. Trusted exchange is the requirement they wrote down. TEFCA and the state HIE are where a great deal of that trust already has a participation agreement, a permitted purpose, and an operator.

If I am sitting with a Medicaid agency or a health-system interoperability lead this year, the question I want on the table is plain. Which trusted flow does this tool depend on. Who is accountable when the record is late or wrong. Does that flow already exist under TEFCA, an HIE, Carequality, or a CMS Aligned Network. A new pipeline with no agreement behind it has not met the roadmap’s own test.

I will keep reading as the policy moves. The sentence I will hold the document to is the one CMS already wrote.

Document behind this note: CMS, A Clinical Super Intelligence Roadmap.

Write to Nick Regier if this is the decision in front of you.